Top 5 Best Carbon Arrows for Hunting Reviews

    Best Carbon Arrows

    If you want to become a successful bow hunter, the right carbon arrows are must-have accessories. These arrows have a solid reputation in the hunting community for good reasons; they offer high levels of accuracy, depict excellent performance, and are very reliable.

    ​Since every company producing carbon arrows presents their units as the best in the market, it becomes hard to differentiate the premium hunting arrows from the fake. Besides that, there is a fair level of technical details and measurements involved, making the whole buying process seem like math homework. But you can now rest assured that we've done thorough research to make this guide as informative as possible.

    Top 5 Best Carbon Arrows - Comparison Table

    ** Below, you will find buying guide as well as our review of each particular product, but you can also click links above to see the current price and customer reviews on Amazon

    Choosing the Best Carbon Arrows

    choosing carbon arrow

    Working with badly constructed or an incorrectly sized arrow is not going to give you the best performance and presents a safety hazard. To be sure you get what you pay for; here are the key factors you need to take into consideration before buying any arrow:

    Arrow Diameter

    Should you purchase an ultra micro-diameter arrow or go with a mid-sized arrow? Carbon arrows have a relatively small diameter but remember they are not all created the same. Micro-diameter arrows have a less surface area and a friction behind the broadhead, which are primarily responsible for deep penetration.

    The reduced surface area also helps minimize the amount of drift on a windy day; therefore, maintaining momentum for a longer period. As for the mid-sized arrows, they may not fly far as much or offer deep penetration as micro diameter arrows.

    Weight (grains)

    The lighter weight arrows give impressive speed numbers that you can easily achieve. These types of arrows tend to travel faster and straighter in the air, hence much easier to shoot even in tight groups. Heavier arrows, on the other hand, are excellent at delivering more penetration power to cause extreme damage on your prey; however, they won't travel as far as lighter arrows.​


    This is another key component that also needs consideration. Don't cut your chances on accuracy by purchasing an arrow of lesser quality. Most of the top carbon arrows you'll find on the market today have a straightness tolerance of 0.001 to 0.004 inches, whereas the standard arrows offer 0.005 to 0.006 inches. And the lower the tolerance, the more expensive the arrow will typically be.​

    Arrow Spine

    How much the shaft resists being bent is one of the most critical aspects that shouldn't be ignored. Keep in mind that the degree of stiffness will affect the level of accuracy. Therefore, it would be best that you select an arrow that's stiff enough; not very limber or too stiff for your bow setup.​

    Don't always be deceived by the high price. Also, it will do you good to look past brand names and purchase an arrow based on quality-rich features of performance and the value you need. The stickers included on the arrows are only for your truck.

    Our 5 Best Carbon Arrows

    1. Carbon Express Maxima Red Fletched Arrows (6-pack)



    This is one of the top carbon hunting arrows from Carbon Express; a pioneer in producing finer arrows for hunting. These arrows are uniquely designed with a state of art design, precisely to provide improved broadhead accuracy and performance. Well, the stiff ends feature an in-flight flexing that is primarily responsible for this outcome.

    The arrows have a 0.417-inch spine and 0.295-inch cutting diameter, which is good enough to cause great damage on your prey. What I like most about these 250-size arrows is that they can cover bows with draw weights from 40-80 pounds. Also, their shaft straightness is laser calculated to a notable 1/10,000 of an inch to have a straightness tolerance of +-0.0025 inches.

    The excellent additional features of the carbon express maxima red-fletched arrows make them stand out from other units on the market. These features include LAUNCHPAD Precision Nocks for better and controlled arrow releases, and BullDog nock collars to protect the arrows against nock-end impacts. The blazer performance vanes are textured for smooth penetration while increasing speed.


    • Premium quality arrow
    • Fly straight
    • Excellent performance and accuracy
    • Ideal for long-range shooting
    • Easy to spot in the tall grass
    • Excellent durability
    • Better groupings
    • Reasonable priced


    • Only shipped within the USA

    Conclusion: Up your game and improve your shooting with the Carbon Express Maxima Red fletched arrow. With this unit, accuracy is completely out of the question. And considering the fact that you'll get LAUNCHPAD Precision Nocks, BullDog nock collars, and blazer vanes, they are worth every penny.

    2. Barnett Outdoors Carbon Crossbow 20 inch arrows (5 pack)



    Barnett is another renowned company that has been manufacturing very high-quality arrows for decades now. They have done it again with Barnett Outdoors Carbon Crossbow 20 inch line of hunting arrows. The arrows weigh 8.1 ounces and come with a lightweight shaft. These bolts are 13.78 grains per inch and match perfectly with 100-grain point for maximum accuracy as well as target penetration.

    The arrows feature a composite of carbon fiber and are produced with an improved wall thickness for more durability. They also come with orange and red fletchings, which make them easier to spot when hunting in tall grass.

    Don't get confused with the moon nocks and field points; they simply refer to the orange tips attached to the arrow near the fletching and the arrow tips respectively.


    • Durable arrows
    • Very sharp tips
    • Very affordable
    • Fly consistently and straight
    • Provide maximum accuracy and penetration
    • Excellent weight ideal for long range shooting
    • Compatible with Wildcat C-5, Ghost 350, 5 Penetrator, and the Jackal crossbow


    • In rare cases, the half-moon knocks may come off

    Conclusion: Outdoors Carbon Arrows provide maximum accuracy and excellent penetrating power; I would recommend these arrows without hesitation. It's never easy to get such a quality unit at a rock bottom price.

    3. 6 - Pk. Carbon Express Maxima Hunter Arrows

    6 - Pk. Carbon Express Maxima Hunter Arrows with Blazer Vanes


    If you think that you've already exploited arrows from Carbon Express, here comes another challenge. The Maxima Hunter Arrows with Blazer Vanes will surely surprise you with their reliable premium properties. The arrows are constructed with Dual Spine Weight Forward Technology for better energy management, allowing them to spin faster while providing faster recovery and unmatched accuracy.

    This product features a sturdy BuffTuff Plus carbon weave construction and Mossy Oak Treestand camo for added durability, BullDog nock collar for increased strength and protection, and Blazer vanes for smooth penetration while enhancing speed.

    The six pack sets are sorted by spine and weight for consistency and optimal accuracy. And just like the previous carbon express arrow, these cross bolts are laser inspected to a shaft straightness tolerance of +/-0.0025. Besides that, they have a weight tolerance of +/- 1.0 grains.

    You can choose from the three kinds of Carbon Maxima Hunter Arrows, which are Maxima 250 (8.0 gr /inch), Maxima 350 (8.9 gr /inch), and Maxima 450 (9.7 gr /inch).​


    • Very straight and accurate
    • Produce the best speed
    • Very strong bolts
    • Lightweight
    • Inexpensive
    • Comes in different sizes
    • Very sustainable fletchings


    • You can't purchase the arrows if you're below 18 years
    • Cannot be shipped to Canada, Massachusetts, or Puerto Rico
    • Have green and white vanes hence hard to spot them in tall grass

    Conclusion: In general, the 6 - Pk. Carbon Express Maxima Hunter Arrows fly excellently, are lightweight and will be ideal for long range shooting. Also, the durability and performance are incredible!

    4. Carbon Express Maxima RED 12 (Pack)

    Carbon Express Maxima RED Carbon Arrow Shaft with Dynamic Spine Control, 12-Pack


    We are not yet done with Carbon Express! Maxima RED 12 (Pack) is another fine product designed for greater speed and accuracy.

    First and foremost, the arrows are well-constructed with a patented technology to control the dynamic spine in a new version so that the broadheads fly better and shoot more consistently. The fact that they are built of Hi-tech carbon material makes them incredibly strong and durable.

    The product features 0.417-inch Spine and 0.295-inch diameter, and is available in 250-size of 8.11 grains per inch. These 12 arrows are sorted and matched by weight and spine for best-in-class consistency. Also, they are laser checked to have a straightness tolerance of +/- 0.0025-inches. Please note that these are maximum measurements, not an average.

    Crucial; the arrows have bare shafts which come with the BullDog Nock Collars and LAUNCHPAD Precision Nocks.


    • Perfect stability
    • High speed
    • Very durable
    • Super accurate
    • Lightweight bolts


    • No vanes
    • A little expensive
    • Not eligible for international shipping

    Conclusion: I would recommend this product to professionals, but not for newbies. Very fast, reliable and accurate. And though they are a little pricey, they deliver the value you pay for. Trust me; you can't go wrong with these arrows.

    5. Excalibur Diablo 18in. Carbon Arrows (6Pack)

    Excalibur Diablo 18in. Carbon Arrows (for Matrix) 6pk


    If you are looking for carbon arrow that's designed for your compact recurve crossbow, Excalibur Diablo 18in. is the best option. It features 2-inch vanes that are textured to make them slick in the air and provide the needed lubrication for smooth operation while increasing the speed of the arrow.

    My love for these bolts is that they can be fitted with both mechanical and fixed broadheads. Also, they are designed with a heavier front insert to increase front-of-center (FOC) weight for excellent performance and unmatched accuracy. There is a flatback insert which eliminates the need for Nocks, giving you more reliable contact with the string. Overall, the craftsmanship is superb.

    These Carbon Excalibur Diablo 18in. Arrows come with red fletchings, which are very easy to spot in tall grass unlike the green and black fletchings.

    Crucial; the arrows have bare shafts which come with the BullDog Nock Collars and LAUNCHPAD Precision Nocks.


    • Solid pieces
    • Remarkably accurate
    • Affordably priced
    • Hard-hitting performance
    • Easy to spot in the tall grass
    • Ideal for relatively long range shooting


    • Available only within the U.S

    Conclusion: To conclude, the Excalibur Diablo 18in. Carbon arrows provide unparalleled accuracy and penetrating powers. Because the bolts are affordable, they are worth giving a consideration. You won't regret!

    Our Pick

    Carbon Express Maxima Red Fletched Arrows (6-pack) take the title here. Many customers highly praise these premium arrows for their high-quality, accurate, and consistent performance. Addition to that, they are affordably priced, making them extremely hard to beat.

    Final Thoughts

    All these are the best carbon arrows; however, you'll have to pick the one that will match your needs for your budget. Up your game today!

    Leave a comment: