Elk are tough animals! If you stick in elk with the Broadhead, he may run 10 miles before he realizes he’s even dead. It’s not uncommon for archers to have a perfect shot, but use an ill advised broadhead to bring down his animal, and never see it again.
It is not ethical for archery hunter to use a lightweight or expendable Broadhead on an elk. You’re going to need a sturdy fixed blade Broadhead with a large cutting diameter that is extra sharp to get the performance you need.
Thankfully, there’s never been a better time for archers who need heavy duty broadheads. There are more on the market with better designs and better materials than ever before. Here are the five most recommended and best broadhead for elk on the market, stick to these and you won’t be wondering whether or not your gear is up to par when a trophy bull is in your sight.
Best Broadhead for Elk – Comparison Table
Fixed vs. Expandable
If you are going to be chasing elk through the high country the season, you are going to need to use a fixed blade Broadhead. In many states is the law. Most every professional hunting camp around the West will require fixed Blade broadheads for chasing elk simply because every expandable Broadhead on the market will not perform as well on game as a fixed broad head.
That’s not to say there aren’t some excellent expendable broadheads on the market, they just aren’t up to the standard of hunting big boned animals like elk in an environment where a few hundred yards can mean the difference of falling off the cliff and is not recovering the animal, and is successful and memorable hunt.
Also consider the fact that many expendable Broadhead’s only use a two bladed design. This is fine on thin-skinned gain like deer but I heavy big boned animals like elk with thick fur a two-dimensional one channel can easily be blocked off or secured and not leave a blood trail. A three-dimensional one channel is sure to always leave plenty of blood for trailing and won’t close up no matter what.
While it’s true the exterior ballistics of a fixed broad head are far superior. They fly flatter with greater accuracy, but the risk of the Broadhead breaking or not opening, or not having enough energy to travel through the animal once the blades open up makes for uneasiness you don’t want on your hunt. Stick to the best fixed broadheads for elk, and follow all local game laws and regulations. When in doubt, find an experienced guide or other elk hunter and get in informed opinion if you are on the fence.
Best Broadhead for Elk Reviews
Muzzy is by far the most popular name in fixed broadheads. They make a ton of different models and have been a stable of people in all budgets for decades. This is their most appropriate Broadhead for elk hunting because not only is an extremely cost-effective and incorporates a design that performs well on heavy big bone game like elk and the lesser bears.
These broadheads are sold in a six pack making them half the cost of what other high-quality broadheads will run you. That is excellent because they are on the harder side to sharpen, but what you can do is use three to dial in your site set up and tune your arrows. Leaving three brand-new out of the box that you have to barely go over to get them sharp.
Muzzy is known for having sharp broadheads out of the box and these four Blade broadheads with a trocar tip are no exception. Be careful with your shot placement however because these blades are on the thinner side and the body is made up of aluminum. They will fly straighter than some of the larger steel plated designs that catch the wind more, but are more fragile in the field. It’s a trade-off you have to decide you’re willing to make but many hunters don’t find a problem with these broadheads.
- Extremely cost effective
- 4 blade design
- Trocar tip
- Thin blades
- Aluminum body
- Hard to sharpen
G5 outdoors is a premium company that makes top shelf equipment. This is one of their best broadheads and is quickly becoming one of the most popular fixed broadheads on the market. It is a three-bladed design that is solid stainless steel and is as beefy as they come. When you pick it up it feels like a solid block of metal with a few razor blades carved out of it, mostly because that’s what it is!
This heavy-duty Broadhead performed excellent on all sorts of game but really shines on close in situations with heavy boned animals like elk. You simply cannot destroy these broadheads by shooting them, they are just too beefy and get the job done no matter what. Their greatest asset by far however, is how they are to sharpen.
The evening clean lines of this Broadhead make them easy to sharpen and there’s plenty of meat there to home for years to come. The stainless-steel construction means you don’t have to worry about rusting but the bulkiness of the Broadhead does not lend itself to being carried in a quiver. Make sure when loading and unloading these broadheads you take your time and don’t bang them around. They are rugged as all get out but just as susceptible to dolling as any other broadhead.
- Stainless steel
- Beefy design
- High quality
In terms of overall mass and ruggedness this broadhead from Marjorie is one of the best on the market. It is a four blade design that features a cut on contact double reinforced tip that punches through hide and deflects off of top bone while the razor thin rear blades work to extend the cutting diameter and penetrate deeply causing massive damage to the animal.
For elk, you won’t find any better than this sort of design. It has a rugged tip extra sharp blades and overall compact size, with just enough cutting diameter to get you through the animal can cause a good blood trail and kill the animal.
It can be a tad difficult to sharpen this design because of how close the cutting blades are together. It definitely takes some practice to get good at it. Overall though, you can count on these broadheads to get the job done in the worst conditions, even on tough big bone game like elk.
- 4 blade design
- Cut on contact
- Flies straight
- Hard to sharpen
This broadhead is like many other classic three bladed broadheads with a trocar tip. Very similar to Muzzy broadheads with one notable exception, these broadheads are 100% steel. Unlike many of the other cheaper options on the market these broadheads don’t sacrifice durability for cost and maintain a steel shank that bonds all three of the blades together.
The three-bladed design has enough diameter to make it legal in many states and is uncrowded making it easy to sharpen. There’s not much steel here to sharpen so you may not get as many uses out of these broadheads as others but wasp has done a great job of striking a good level of price and usability with these broadheads.
If there’s one problem with this Broadhead it’s that the trocar tip on the end of the Broadhead that makes it penetrate in a straight line, makes it not cut on contact. If you don’t get a full pass through, as is common with heavy game like elk, you may have a trouble blood trailing because this broadhead penetrates in a way that doesn’t leave very much of an entrance wound. Be on the lookout for even the faintest signs of blood.
- Trocar tip
- Easy to sharpen
- Steel construction
- Not cut on contact
- 3 bladed design
This is a classically designed for blade Broadhead that works great for elk hunting because of the mass behind the blades and how easy it is to sharpen. The most important aspect of this blade is that is cut on contact and it is sturdy. That sturdiness and instant ability to slice as soon as it contacts the height of the animal means this Broadhead penetrates deep with two main cutting blades, and to secondary bleeder blades that are removable.
There’s removable blades make the Broadhead easy to sharpen, versus a one-piece design and the entire Broadhead is exceptionally sturdy and well-built once assembled. Without the secondary bleeder blades installed the two-blade design isn’t as balanced and shouldn’t be used without them.
This is a high-quality blade that you can depend on to get the job done elk. It is on the bulkier side and will catch the wind easily with large main blades but dialing in your set up and making sure you don’t punch them up too closely your quiver will keep you from having this problem.
Just make sure that you field-tested the arrows before a big client, and you keep them nice and sharp. Big broadheads like these suffer the worst when it comes to dullness and effects on the blades. Don’t make that mistake!
- Penetrates deep
- 4 bladed design
- Removable blades
- Easy to sharpen
- Cut on contact
Size & Cutting Diameter
The size and cutting diameter of your broadhead should be as big as you can reasonably make it. The more blades in the larger the cutting diameter the more damage it will do on impact. All things being equal, a larger cutting diameter will always be better. The trade-off in the real world however, is that large broadheads fly in erratic ways especially when exposed to winds and awkward shooting conditions. If you are going on a guided hunt ask your guide how big of a broad head you should bring.
Most guides will agree for elk you need it least a 1 inch cutting diameter broadhead, with three or more blades and it must be a fixed blade broadhead. The fixed blade Broadhead is much sturdier than any expandable, a 1 inch cutting diameter is large enough to ensure you will hit a vital with a well-placed shot, and the three bladed design cuts a three-dimensional wound channel that will close up as the animal runs away.
If you are headed out on a once-in-a-lifetime elk hunt, don’t skimp on your equipment. Especially, you’re broadheads. No other part of your equipment contacts the animal and the cutting edge of your arrow needs to be the best you can get your hands on. A large diameter fixed blade Broadhead is hard to beat for destruction and killing power on an arrow.
If you are headed out on elk hunt that simply cannot be compromised for, stick to one of the five best broadhead for elk designs seen here, get into the field into of your bow prior to your hunt and you won’t have any questions or doubts when you’re in the high country with bowls sounding off all around you!
Last update on 2021-09-28 at 10:16 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API